kvalitetsforskjell mellom CDR-fabrikanter

[karl hungus]

jeg fant denne testen her, som jeg tror ikke er helt fersk, og er forbauset over at ikke Verbatim får toppkarakter.. noen som har synspunkter på rangeringen?

 

 

 

http://www.cdmediaworld.com/hardware/cdrom...d_quality.shtml

 

Both Before and After tests were compared and here are the results of the test:

Brand Factory Quality Misc

Imation Taiyo Yuden Good

Kodak Kodak Good

Philips Gold Kodak Good

TraxData Gold Kodak Good

Philips Silver Taiyo Yuden Good

Ricoh Premium Ricoh Good

Sony Taiyo Yuden Good

TDK TDK Good

NoName Mitsubishi Mitsubishi Medium

Ricoh Standard Ricoh Medium

That's Taiyo Yuden Medium

Arita Ritek Bad

Philips IQ Silver Ritek Bad Problems writing the "aged" CD-R's

TraxData Silver Ritek Bad

NoName Ritek Ritek Bad

FujiFilm Ritek Bad Problems writing the "aged" CD-R's

NoName Fornet Fornet Bad

 

Good Quality Results:

 

Do not have any problems with the aging process.

Don't have errors.

Can write at all speeds it is supposed to be able to handle.

Medium Quality Results:

 

Don't have major problems with the aging process.

Still have errors which can't be corrected.

Bad Quality Results:

 

Totally can't handle the aging process.

Too many errors which can't be corrected.

Are not suited to record AUDIO data.

Have problems writing at speeds higher than 1x.

The article also encountered a very bad TraxData Silver batch (which came in softcase), which was very sensitive to UV light. While testing the CD-R's a lot of errors were encountered exactly where there was no print on the label (so you could "read" the Traxdata logo in the errors!) It seemed that the ink was hardened with UV light thus causing the errors.

This faulty batch was replaced by TraxData for a "better" one before the above results

[lavizh]

Verbatim?? ... de produserer jo skikkelig shitty CD'R da. . Min mening er at TDK er best.

[karl hungus]

TDK?

Selv har jeg alltid holdt en knapp på Kodak...

 

artikkel jeg fant om TDK for kveruleringens skyld:

 

TDK Inferior Quality CD-R's

 

 

 

IQ = Inferior Quality

 

Name TDK CD-R74 IQ

ATIP 97m 31s 02f

Dye Type Cyanine (Type 2)

Factory Ritek Co.

Color Top -

Color Label -

Color Dye -

Capacity 656.69MB (74m 45s 00f / LBA: 336225)

CD-Writer -

Info By selling RiTEK made CD-R's TDK has seriously damaged their credibility of selling quality CD-R media, as stores don't know the difference between these CD-R's and just sell them for one price. Usually this price is higher than the regular RiTEK made CD-R's. So check the package before buying TDK CD-R's!

Pictures ?

 

Name TDK CD-RCF74EA IQ

ATIP 97m 31s 01f

Factory Ritek Co.

Dye Type Cyanine (Type 1)

Color Top Silver

Color Label Silver

Color Dye Blue

Capacity 656.69 MB (74:45:00 / LBA: 336225)

CD-Writer Teac CD-R56S

Speed 1x-8x

OverSize -

Info By selling RiTEK made CD-R's TDK has seriously damaged their credibility of selling quality CD-R media, as stores don't know the difference between these CD-R's and just sell them for one price. Usually this price is higher than the regular RiTEK made CD-R's. So check the package before buying TDK CD-R's!