X850XT eller 6800 Ultra?

[ATWindsor]

Har samlet talle fra testene på HardOCP, tallene er min FPS i prosent av average FPS (høyere prosent er bedre). De første 6 er med forskjellige settings på kortene. Mens de fire siste er med samme settings (uten AF og AA og med).

 

Med forbehold om regnefei

 

Ati Nvidia

 

D3

52.0 50.8

 

FC

62.0 56.2

 

Hl2

25.2 50.5

 

NfSU

65.7 72.9

 

MNFL

73.8 41.7

 

SWB

66.0 68.0

 

 

 

D3 AA

49.6 50.8

 

D3

53.0 72.4

 

FC AA

62.0 59.3

 

FC

57.1 52.4

 

AtW

Endret 27. mars 2005 av ATWindsor

[apwr]

Jeg har jo som sagt et GeForce 6800GT selv men synes det høres rart ut at Ati kortene "sliter" med Half Life 2 i forhold til nVidia. Hadde dette virkelig vært tilfelle så tror jeg nok vi ville hørt mer om det på www.

ATi sliter med HL2? Ehhh nei, har sitti å spilt det en time eller så her nå og FPS gikk aldri under 50 med 6aa, 8af, 1280*1024 og alle innstillinger på maks! FPS lå jevnt over 100 og hvis det ikke er akseptabelt så vet ikke jeg...

Hvis du leser litt bedre, så ser du at han skriver at det høres rart ut at ATI-kortene sliter med HL2 i forhold til Nvidia. Han mener nemlig at ATI-kortene ikke sliter.

[ATWindsor]

Man kan jo bite seg merke i at forskjellene i framedrop er små, untatt i madden, i ati sin favør, og HL2 i nvidia sin favør (der ati får noen overraskende store drops, kan det være cpu som spiller inn?).

 

AtW

[LWSR54]

Real-World Performance:

 

Despite ATI's recent introduction of Catalyst AI, the GeForce 6800Ultra still outguns ATI's best in a real-world scenario. It out-does it in terms of image quality, while returning a frame rate that is as playable, if not more so than the X800 XT Platinum Edition. The XFX GeForce 6800Ultra is another step beyond this, it delivers the same image quality and a frame rate that is even smoother than what can be achieved by the reference-speed GeForce 6800Ultra.

 

Aside from the reflection bug in Far Cry, the achievable image quality and performance has improved greatly in the later ForceWare driver versions, and once the problems with below-par image quality are fixed, we can expect the XFX GeForce 6800Ultra to be capable of delivering image quality and performance that is as impressive as what the X800 XT Platinum Edition is capable of delivering in this title.

 

If you're a real-time strategy fanatic, there is pretty much no competition for the GeForce 6800Ultra, and XFX's implementation of this board is yet another step ahead too - ATI's best just cannot keep up with NVIDIA's best in both Rome: Total War and more so Warhammer 40,000: Dawn Of War. The XFX is capable of running at both a higher image quality and a smoother frame rate than the X800 XT Platinum Edition by either increasing AA and AF settings, increasing in-game resolution or because ATI's best was not capable of running at the highest detail settings.

 

Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow proved to be a very solid performer on all three configurations, but again, the highly-clocked XFX GeForce 6800Ultra delivered the best playable image quality, with the X800 XT Platinum not too far behind. The general optimisations within Catalyst AI are proving to work well for ATI, and they're bridging the gap in titles where before they were unable to perform closely to the higher-clocked GeForce 6800Ultra's, such as the XFX.

 

Need For Speed: Underground proved to be a dead-heat in terms of performance, and we believe that this title is not as graphically limited as it once was - the fact that we have maximised both the driver settings and the in-game detail settings proves that we have got to the stage where performance in the title is determined by the CPU and general system bandwidth

 

her er en sammendrag fra kortene i forskjellige spill 6800 wins

Endret 27. mars 2005 av LWSR54

[Aurgjelme]

kan det være cpu som spiller inn?

 

kan være. hl2 er et spill som, med høye instillinger, krever mye av cpu også